January 28, 2012

Missing E-mail from London Student and New Link

For those of you who enjoy reading about Art Therapy and neuroscience, here is link to a list of publications by Noah Hass-Cohen that might be useful: http://noahhasscohen.com/my-publications.html

Also, I recently received an e-mail from a student in London, but I must have accidentally deleted it. I'm disappointed because I really wanted to respond. Perhaps she will read this post.

As I recall, the question in the e-mail was in preparation for an in-class debate: "Why might a neuroscience model for art therapy be beneficial?" The student mentioned a comparison between a neuroscience and a psychodynamic model of Art Therapy.

In the US, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy is a reimbursable form of therapy. The status that CBT has with insurers and funding agencies is a result of concrete and measurable goals, goal-focused processes and clear outcomes-based evaluations/results.

Some theoretical models related to Art Therapy include psychodynamic psychotherapy which is similar to psychoanalysis in that the primary focus is to reveal unconscious material. Concrete goals and goal-focused processes are not central tenets of the theoretical framework.

'Art as healing' has become a buzz-phrase within the field of Art Therapy. However, this statement may be viewed as meaningless.

What is art 'healing' exactly? How is it 'healing' this part of a person? Where is measured proof that something has been 'healed' as a direct result of Art Therapy?

Armed with a neuro-scientific perspective, Art Therapists can outline art-making processes in a way that is more meaningful. For instance, saying that art-as-therapy promotes EEG rhythms to increase in alpha frequency, thus decreasing behavioral symptoms of anxiety is more concrete, can be measured, and sessions can be structured around EEG readings.

Likewise, saying that creating emotion-centered images aims to promote brain activity in the limbic system and simultaneously engage the hippocampus, thus encouraging enhanced cognitive performance is concrete, can be evaluated, and clear goals can be established. Cognitive performance pre and post treatment can be measured, for instance. Art directives can be systematically oriented towards positive, emotion-centered image-making, and discussions can be focused on reminiscence.

Art Therapy descriptions phrased around neuroscience themes may become more concrete, goal-oriented, and outcome-based. Whether or not this is "better" is debatable. However, from this perspective, Art Therapy becomes a linear, clear-cut process, that may be more insurable and funding-friendly. I, for one, like that idea.

I hope this helps!


Max Moreno said...

The Benefits of a Physical Therapy Career include the intrinsic rewards of life as a PTA. In other words, you are helping people each and every day of your career, and having a direct role in. Click here for the details.

Negi said...

Thanks for great information you write it very clean. I am very lucky to get this tips from you

psychotherapist nyc

Stanley Workman said...


Quatrune Brain: a mind map that includes the arts said...

Thanks you for this very useful summary of Haas-Cohen work, which is extensive. I greatly appreciated this BLOG and feel it is very timely. I am further developing my CONED work, presented to AATA and AT Grad Programs in the 1980's. It is now called the Quatrune Brain Brain~Mind Map. Will shae it with you here soon. Thanx for this useful e-site. Roberta Shoemaker-Beal, interested and working with neuro-art therapy education since the 1970's.

Freshmind Therapy said...

You have shared a great information about Psychodynamic Therapy London and Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy

.Which are very informative for us.Thanks

Alex said...

Excellently written article, if only all blogger offered the same level of content as you, the internet would be a much better place. Please keep it up!.Great tips, I would like to join your blog anyway.Waiting for some more review.Thank you
Arm Pain Treatment
Back Pain Treatment
Failed Back Surgery
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Treatments
Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS)
Chronic Headache Treatments
Joint Pain Treatments
Chronic Musculoskeletal Pain Treatments